top of page

The Art of ETF Rebalancing: How Frequently Should You Make Adjustments?



woman sitting at a desk with computers pointing to something with a pen

As an investor, one of the key decisions you need to make is how frequently you should rebalance your ETF portfolio. Rebalancing involves adjusting the allocation of different assets within your portfolio to maintain the desired investment strategy. But determining the right timing for rebalancing can be a challenge.


In this article, we delve into the art of ETF rebalancing and explore the optimal frequency for adjusting your portfolio and the practices we follow at Life Story Financial. We examine the potential benefits and drawbacks of different approaches – from annual rebalancing to more frequent adjustments.


By understanding the factors that influence rebalancing decisions, you'll be equipped with the knowledge to make informed choices that align with your investment goals and risk tolerance. We'll also discuss the role of automation and technology in streamlining the rebalancing process.


Whether you're a novice investor or a seasoned pro, mastering the art of ETF rebalancing is crucial to optimizing your portfolio's performance. So let's dive in and discover how to strike the perfect balance for your investments.


Understanding the importance of rebalancing


Rebalancing is a crucial aspect of managing an ETF portfolio. It involves periodically adjusting the allocation of different assets within your portfolio to maintain the desired investment strategy. The main goal of rebalancing is to restore your portfolio to its original asset allocation, ensuring that it remains aligned with your investment objectives and risk tolerance.


When you initially set up your portfolio, you carefully choose the allocation of assets based on your investment goals, time horizon, and risk appetite. Over time, market fluctuations can cause the value of different assets to deviate from their target allocation.


For example, if stocks perform exceptionally well while bonds lag behind, your portfolio may become overweighted in stocks, exposing you to increased risk. Rebalancing allows you to trim your winners and buy more of the underperforming assets (in this case bonds), helping you maintain a balanced and diversified investment approach.


Factors to Consider When Deciding How Frequently to Rebalance


Determining the optimal frequency for rebalancing your ETF portfolio depends on several factors. Here are some key considerations to keep in mind:


  • Investment horizon: Your investment time horizon plays a significant role in deciding how frequently you should rebalance. If you have a longer-term investment horizon, you may not need to rebalance as frequently since short-term market fluctuations are less likely to significantly impact your portfolio. On the other hand, if you have a shorter investment horizon, more frequent rebalancing may be necessary to ensure your portfolio remains aligned with your goals.

  • Risk tolerance: Your risk tolerance is another crucial factor to consider. If you have a higher risk tolerance and can tolerate larger fluctuations in your portfolio, you may opt for less frequent rebalancing. Conversely, if you have a lower risk tolerance and prefer a more conservative approach, more frequent rebalancing can help you maintain the desired risk level.

  • Asset class volatility: Different asset classes have varying levels of volatility. If your portfolio contains highly volatile assets, more frequent rebalancing may be necessary to prevent your portfolio from becoming too heavily weighted in one asset class. On the other hand, if your portfolio consists of less volatile assets, rebalancing less frequently may be sufficient.

  • Transaction costs: Rebalancing incurs transaction costs, such as brokerage fees and bid-ask spreads. These costs can eat into your returns, especially if you rebalance too frequently. Therefore, it's essential to consider the impact of transaction costs on your portfolio's overall performance when deciding how frequently to rebalance.


Different rebalancing strategies - time-based, threshold-based, and hybrid approaches

There are several approaches you can take when it comes to rebalancing your ETF portfolio.


Here are three common strategies:


  1. Time-based rebalancing: With this approach, you rebalance your portfolio at fixed time intervals, such as annually, semi-annually, or quarterly. Time-based rebalancing takes the emotion and guesswork out of the equation, providing a systematic approach to maintaining your desired asset allocation. However, it may not be the most efficient strategy if market conditions change significantly between rebalancing periods.

  2. Threshold-based rebalancing: This strategy involves setting specific thresholds for each asset class within your portfolio. When the deviation from the target allocation exceeds the predetermined threshold, you rebalance. For example, if your target allocation for stocks is 50%, and it deviates by more than 5%, you would rebalance to bring it back to 50%. Threshold-based rebalancing allows for more flexibility and responsiveness to market conditions. However, it requires regular monitoring and adjustment of thresholds.

  3. Hybrid approach: A hybrid approach combines elements of both time-based and threshold-based rebalancing. For example, you may choose to rebalance annually but also incorporate specific thresholds to trigger rebalancing if deviations exceed a certain percentage. This approach combines the benefits of both strategies, providing a disciplined and adaptable approach to portfolio rebalancing.


Each strategy has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the optimal approach may vary depending on your individual circumstances and preferences.


Best Practices for Successful ETF Rebalancing


The importance of rebalancing


Maintaining a balanced portfolio is essential for long-term investment success. Over time, market fluctuations can cause the asset allocation in your portfolio to deviate from your original investment strategy. This imbalance can lead to increased risk or missed opportunities for growth. Rebalancing allows you to bring your portfolio back in line with your desired asset allocation, ensuring that you stay on track towards your investment goals.


There are two primary reasons why rebalancing is important.

  • First, it helps to control risk. By periodically rebalancing, you can prevent your portfolio from becoming too heavily weighted towards a particular asset class that may be experiencing a temporary surge. This helps to mitigate the risk of significant losses if that asset class suddenly declines.

  • Second, rebalancing allows you to take advantage of market opportunities. By selling assets that have performed well and reallocating the proceeds to underperforming assets, you can potentially increase your returns over time.


However, it's important to note that rebalancing should not be done too frequently. Frequent rebalancing can result in unnecessary transaction costs and taxes, which can eat into your overall returns. Finding the right balance between too little and too much rebalancing is key.


Annual rebalancing: a conservative approach


One of the most common approaches to rebalancing is to do it on an annual basis, which is standard practice for the portfolios we manage at Life Story Financial through our investment management service. This conservative approach involves reviewing your portfolio annually and making adjustments as necessary to bring it back in line with your target asset allocation.


Annual rebalancing has several advantages. It provides a structured and disciplined approach to portfolio management, ensuring that you regularly review and adjust your investments. It also minimizes the impact of short-term market fluctuations on your portfolio, as you're not reacting to every minor change in the market.


However, a potential drawback of annual rebalancing is that it may result in missed opportunities for growth. If a particular asset class experiences a significant increase in value between rebalancing periods, you may miss out on potential gains by not adjusting your allocation sooner. That's why at Life Story Financial we look at your portfolio at least quarterly to make adjustments is necessary during times of big market shifts.


Ultimately, the decision to rebalance annually depends on your investment goals, risk tolerance, and the level of involvement you want in managing your portfolio.


Quarterly or semi-annual rebalancing: a balanced approach


For those investors who want a more active approach to rebalancing without incurring excessive transaction costs, quarterly or semi-annual rebalancing may be a suitable option.

This approach involves reviewing and adjusting your portfolio every three to six months, depending on your preference. By rebalancing more frequently than annually, you can capture gains from assets that have performed well and reallocate them to underperforming assets.


Quarterly or semi-annual rebalancing strikes a balance between capturing short-term opportunities and minimizing transaction costs. It allows you to stay engaged with your investments without becoming overly reactive to every market fluctuation.


However, it's important to consider the potential tax implications of more frequent rebalancing in your taxable investment accounts. (This doesn't apply to tax-deferred accounts such as your 401(k) or individual retirement accounts (IRAs). Depending on your jurisdiction, selling assets within a short period may trigger capital gains taxes.


It's advisable to consult with a tax professional to understand the tax implications before implementing a quarterly or semi-annual rebalancing strategy in your taxable portfolio.


Dynamic or threshold-based rebalancing: a proactive approach


Dynamic or threshold-based rebalancing takes a more proactive approach to portfolio management. Instead of rebalancing on a fixed schedule, this strategy involves setting target thresholds for each asset class and rebalancing when those thresholds are breached.


For example, if your target allocation for stocks is 60%, you may set a threshold of 5%. If the actual allocation of stocks in your portfolio falls below 55% or rises above 65%, you would rebalance to bring it back to the target allocation.


Dynamic rebalancing allows for more flexibility and responsiveness to market conditions. It ensures that your portfolio remains within your desired asset allocation range, without the need for rigid rebalancing schedules.


However, dynamic rebalancing requires regular monitoring of your portfolio to identify when thresholds are breached. It also requires a willingness to make adjustments more frequently, which may not be suitable for all investors.


Overall, dynamic or threshold-based rebalancing is a more proactive and responsive approach to portfolio management. It can be particularly effective during periods of high market volatility or when you anticipate significant changes in market conditions, which is what we do at Life Story Financial.


Tools and Resources for Tracking and Managing ETF Portfolios


Portfolio trackers and management tools


Managing an ETF portfolio can be complex, especially if you have multiple funds and asset classes. Fortunately, there are several online tools and platforms available to help you track and manage your portfolio effectively.


Portfolio trackers allow you to monitor the performance and allocation of your ETF holdings in one centralized location. These tools provide real-time updates on the value of your investments, as well as detailed breakdowns of your asset allocation and performance metrics.


Some popular portfolio tracking tools include Personal Capital, Morningstar, and Yahoo Finance. These platforms offer a range of features, including customizable dashboards, performance analytics, and investment research tools.


In addition to portfolio trackers, there are also portfolio management tools that can automate the rebalancing process. These tools use algorithms to analyze your portfolio and make adjustments based on your target asset allocation. They can help streamline the rebalancing process, saving you time and effort.


Some popular portfolio management tools include Betterment, Wealthfront and Vanguard Personal Advisor Services. If you're working with a financial advisor, they may utilize the portfolio management tools available through turnkey asset management platforms (TAMPs) only available to them. These include AssetMark, Life Story Financial's partner, Orion, Buckingham Strategic Partners and Envestnet, to name a few.


These platforms offer a combination of automated portfolio management and personalized advice to help you optimize your investments on your own or by working with a financial advisor who is investing on your behalf.


Research and educational resources


To make informed decisions about rebalancing your ETF portfolio, it's essential to stay informed about market trends, economic indicators, and investment strategies.


There are numerous resources available to help you deepen your understanding of ETFs and portfolio management. Websites such as Investopedia, ETF.com, and Seeking Alpha provide a wealth of educational articles, tutorials, and market analysis.


In addition to online resources, consider seeking guidance from financial advisors or investment professionals. They can provide personalized advice based on your specific investment goals and risk tolerance.


Attending consumer-focused investment webinars or workshops can also be a great way to expand your knowledge and network with other investors. Many financial institutions and industry organizations host educational events for consumers that cover a wide range of investment topics, including ETFs and portfolio management.


Case studies of successful ETF rebalancing strategies


Case Study 1: Annual rebalancing


John is a conservative investor who prefers a hands-off approach to portfolio management. He has a diversified ETF portfolio consisting of stocks, bonds, and real estate investment trusts (REITs). John rebalances his portfolio annually, typically at the beginning of each year.

By rebalancing annually, John ensures that his portfolio remains aligned with his investment strategy. He reviews his asset allocation and makes adjustments as necessary to bring it back in line with his target allocation.


Over the past five years, John's annual rebalancing strategy has helped him maintain a consistent asset allocation and control risk. While he may miss out on short-term market opportunities, he values the peace of mind that comes with a structured and disciplined approach to portfolio management.


Case Study 2: Quarterly rebalancing


Sarah is an active investor who closely monitors market trends and economic indicators. She believes in taking advantage of short-term market opportunities and adjusting her portfolio accordingly.


Sarah rebalances her portfolio on a quarterly basis. She reviews her asset allocation every three months and makes adjustments based on her target allocation and market conditions.

Sarah's quarterly rebalancing strategy has allowed her to capture gains from assets that have performed well and reallocate them to underperforming assets. This proactive approach has resulted in higher returns compared to a more conservative rebalancing strategy.


However, Sarah is mindful of the transaction costs associated with frequent rebalancing. To mitigate these costs, she uses low-cost ETFs and carefully considers the tax implications of her rebalancing decisions.


Case Study 3: Dynamic rebalancing


Michael is an experienced investor who actively manages his ETF portfolio. He believes in maintaining a dynamic asset allocation that adjusts to changing market conditions.

Michael uses a dynamic rebalancing strategy based on threshold triggers. He sets target thresholds for each asset class in his portfolio and rebalances when those thresholds are breached.


This proactive approach allows Michael to capitalize on market opportunities and manage risk effectively. By rebalancing when asset classes deviate from their target thresholds, he ensures that his portfolio remains within his desired asset allocation range.


Michael's dynamic rebalancing strategy requires regular monitoring of his portfolio and a willingness to make adjustments more frequently. However, he believes that the benefits outweigh the additional effort.


Conclusion and Final Thoughts on Finding the Right Rebalancing Frequency


Determining the optimal frequency for rebalancing your ETF portfolio is a personal decision that depends on your investment goals, risk tolerance, and level of involvement in portfolio management.


Annual rebalancing provides a structured and disciplined approach, minimizing the impact of short-term market fluctuations. This approach may be suitable for conservative investors who prioritize stability and long-term growth.


Quarterly or semi-annual rebalancing strikes a balance between capturing short-term opportunities and minimizing transaction costs. This approach may be suitable for investors who want a more active approach without incurring excessive costs.


Dynamic or threshold-based rebalancing is a proactive approach that allows for flexibility and responsiveness to market conditions. This approach may be suitable for investors who actively manage their portfolios and want to take advantage of short-term market opportunities.


Remember, the decision to rebalance and the frequency at which you do so should align with your investment strategy and risk tolerance. Regular monitoring of your portfolio and staying informed about market trends are key to successful rebalancing.


Lastly, leverage the tools and resources available to you, such as portfolio trackers and management tools, research websites, and advice from financial professionals like Life Story Financial. These resources can help streamline the rebalancing process and enhance your understanding of ETFs and portfolio management.


By mastering the art of ETF rebalancing and finding the right frequency for adjustments, you'll be better equipped to optimize your portfolio's performance and achieve your investment goals.


If you're unsure about the approach you should be taking, you can schedule a free introductory call with Life Story Financial to learn more. Happy rebalancing!


For more investing and money tips like these, download Life Story Financial's FREE smart investing ebook and sign up for our monthly newsletter.

Comments


bottom of page